Reading Comprehension through Harry Styles



I love using music in the classroom for a number of reasons. I have previously blogged about using songs for comprehension and you can read about them here - CLICK HERE.

After listening to the latest song released by Harry Styles, 'Two Ghosts' is definitely a song you could use and discuss with your pupils.

Here is a lyric video:


I would first play the song all the way through and ask the children what the song is about - It is about a relationship ending and both leaving as very different people. 

Then consider the lyrics in more detail:

 Same lips red, same eyes blue,
Same white shirt, couple more tattoos,
But it's not you and it's not me,
Tastes so sweet, looks so real,
Sounds like something that I used to feel,
But I can't touch what I see.

 We're not who we used to be,
We're not who we used to be,
We're just two ghosts standing in the place of you and me,
Trying to remember how it feels to have a heartbeat.


  • Consider the first line, who is he singing about? His partner
  • Who is the second line referencing? Himself
  • What does Harry mean by the third line? Even though they look the same on the outside, they are very different on the inside because of the relationship. 
  •  Why does he make a reference to taste? He isn't going to eat anyone, it is a reference to how sweet she is and how we like sweet things. 
  • How do we know he no longer has the same feelings? He uses the past tense to explain his feelings. 
  • Why does he repeat the line 'We're not who we used to be'? For emphasis, he is making it clear that they have both changed. 
  • Why does he reference himself and his partner as ghosts? Ghosts are apparitions that only resemble the external of the person they were. They do not possess feelings and no longer have a heartbeat. There is no emotional connection between them anymore. 
  • Why does he talk about his heartbeat in the last line? We always link the heart to love so he is trying to remember when he was happy in love. 
  • How long has he felt like this about his relationship? A long time as he can't remember a time when he had a heartbeat - felt in love. 
The fridge light washes this room white,
Moon dances over your good side,
This was all we used to need,
Tongue-tied like we've never known,
Telling those stories we already told,
'Cause we don't say what we really mean.

 We're not who we used to be,
We're not who we used to be,
We're just two ghosts standing in the place of you and me,
We're not who we used to be,
We're not who we used to be,
We're just two ghosts swimming in a glass half empty,
Trying to remember how it feels to have a heartbeat.

 Trying to remember how it feels to have a heartbeat,
I'm just trying to remember how it feels to have a heartbeat
  • Were the couple together for a long time? We can infer yes that they lived together as he talks about the fridge light and repeating stories. 
  • How do we know the excitement of the relationship is gone? He mentions that they needed nothing but light from the fridge or the moon and that was all they needed to be happy together, but that isn't the case anymore. 
  • Why is he tongue-tied? He doesn't know what to say to her and what to talk about anymore. 
  • Who is to blame for the break up? No one in particular, the message from the song is that both people are the same and even Harry admits he can't talk about his real feelings. 
  • Why does he mention swimming in a glass half empty? This references the idiom of glass half full/empty. The reference to emptiness links to pessimism, that you focus on the negatives. 

  • Overall, do you feel this is a sad or happy song? It is sad that a relationship has come to an end however when you aren't happy it is best to end something and move forward but to learn from the experience. 
  • What might Harry have learned from the relationship? To talk more about how he really feels rather than go round in circles and make things worse. 





Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Lovely Poem for Your Leavers Assembly

Image
I am always asked to put a little video together for our Year 6 show and end of year assembly. Each year, I always include a special poem that I finish the end of year video with. It is called Leaving School by Jade Hughes and it is beautiful: We've now left school, It's how the story ends, Tears of happiness is what we recommend,   It's what we say, But there's always a little pain, Because once you've left, It's not the same,   You could walk through school and you would see, Your friends who have grown up incredibly, But now you've gone, It's not the same, As you may never see them again,   Your friends who have grown up right beside you, Who have helped you through your daily strife, Will go ahead and leave behind them, You who wants the same old life,   But you can not live your life in the past, Hoping that the same memories will last, You have to move on and just be glad, That leaving has made you so sad, As this just shows that...
Keep reading

Using Disney Films for Geography!

Image
Last week I came across a tweet sharing this picture: I thought it would be a brilliant way for children to learn about the location of different countries around the world.  Before we looked at the map, I asked the class to list as many animated Disney films (excluding Pixar) as they could think of. We shared some of our ideas and discussed the origins of some of these stories. Some were books, others fairy tales, legends or folk tales.  This gave us a link with Literacy to discuss different types of stories, how most films are derived from written texts and also looking at some famous authors. We also talked about whether they could remember where in the world the film was set.  I then shared the map with the children and gave them time to look and see whether they knew any of the countries themselves. They had to make estimated guesses as to where they thought each film was set. After they had had a go at trying the name all the countries, they t...
Keep reading

Teaching Direct Speech Punctuation using the iPhone text messaging!

Image
Teaching direct speech is always a tricky aspect, there is so much to remember and very few useful visual pictures that clearly help children know what and how to use speech punctuation properly. Lets look at some of the tips to remember: The words that are spoken have to go within the speech marks. Any punctuation needs to also go inside the speech marks. A reporting clause, who and how they said it can go before, middle or end. A comma follows the reporting clause at the beginning. You need to start a new line when a new character speaks.  I think that is most of them?? I have heard of endless different ways to try and get children to remember these tips - keeping the sheeps in the pen  or speech mark sandwich  which are a couple of examples however they do not have any visual help for tips such as starting on a new line, which is something some of my children find hardest to remember.  I decided to use a different approach, to help cover the...
Keep reading